http://www.wordle.net/thumb/wrdl/6338410/Health
Tracey's Practicum III Experience
Wednesday, February 6, 2013
Week 4
Still no placement waiting waiting........................................................
Reading Diagnostic Paper
Reading Diagnostic Paper
The
Evaluation of Reading Diagnostic Tests
Summary
The important role of a teacher is being able to know
their students by determining their strengths and weaknesses. This is an ongoing process where the teacher
wants to see their students to show progress.
The best way is to be aware of the best reading diagnostic assessments
available that will test students in all aspects of reading. The teacher needs to make sure the student is
assigned to right reading level, so they can thrive without frustration. Each school usually has several diagnostic
tests they use for the students. You
need to look at all aspects of reading and make sure the test will properly
measure the student’s reading level and be to diagnose any reading problems. The best strategy would be not to rely on one
assessment for accuracy and reliability, but take a look at several. Additionally, the students need to be tested
on a regular basis because a test only measures the student’s ability at that
point in time. Most tests are quick
screening tools that help the teacher identify problems and confirm reading
levels for students. The test can
measure vocabulary, reading word lists, phonics, oral and silent reading,
reading comprehension, visual cues, reading fluency, etc. A teacher wants to
look at the best assessments for their class in order to make effective
decisions. The students look at their
assessment results as a way to confirm their skills by being able to their
progress.
The table will below
will describe in detail the purpose, appropriateness, strengths, and weaknesses
of five widely used reading assessments.
The Basic Reading Inventory is a quick assessment that provides a solid
base for a teacher to create a reading plan from testing the student on sight
words and word passages. Slosson Intelligence Test Primary (SIT-P) is used in
early education to identify any problems students may have in reading. The Slosson Oral Reading Test and Wepman’s
Auditory Discrimination Test are quick screening tools that should be used with
other assessments. Visual Motor
Integration Test helps diagnose students with visual discrimination issues that
can cause problems in reading. Gray’s
Diagnostic Reading Test is very reliable and the result would stand on its own;
however, you should always look at more than one assessment.
Reading Diagnostic Assessment Table
Test
|
Purpose
|
Strengths
|
Weaknesses
|
Appropriateness
|
Basic
Reading Inventory (BRI) Test
|
BRI
is an easy assessment to administer to determine the level of the reader by
evaluating their reading fluency by measuring accuracy, rate, and prosody.
The
BRI test the student on grade level sight words and passages with
comprehension questions, timed reading to determine a student’s rate of how
many words per minute they can read.
Both silent and oral reading is measured.
The
assessment can measure how many words they got right, substitute or get
wrong. This helps create a reading
plan based on the student’s reading level.
|
A
valuable diagnostic tool
to
find the instructional level and evaluate the student on right grade leveled
word lists or reading passages.
The
teacher can individually evaluate the students and place the students in
reading groups and provide reading materials based on their instructional
level.
The
teacher can quickly measure reading fluency and comprehension and determine
what direction to take his/her instruction.
|
There
is no clear separation narrative or expository passages lacking a good
balance between the two
Most
passages are drawn from textbooks instead of stories
Differences
in passage lengths
Variability
in measures based on the type of BRI assessment used on student
Comprehension
questions are informal and can affect the normal classification scheme of
reading comprehension
|
This
a good assessment tools to help group students and developing reading plans
to help them grow and improve.
This
is a good starting point and the teacher can conduct other assessments to
confirm the BRI results.
The
BRI provides consistent results that help the students enhance reading skills
with less frustration.
|
Gray
Diagnostic Reading Test (Psychological Reading Test)
|
GORT-4
measures the growth in oral reading and an aid in diagnosing reading
difficulties. It is for 6-18 yr. olds
The
assessment has five scores that reflects rate, accuracy, fluency,
comprehension and overall reading ability
It
has developmentally sequenced reading passages with five comprehension
questions following each passage.
Identifies
students who are below their peers in oral reading proficiency, diagnose
specific reading strengths and weaknesses, and document student reading
growth as a result of special intervention.
|
The
test is takes in account in its passages the differences of key demographic
variables such as race, gender, ethnicity, and geographic region
Provide
reliable and consistent measures of students where teachers can develop
appropriate lessons and have the students groups in the appropriate reading
leveled groups
The
results help diagnose reading problems with students
|
Even
though the assessment takes in accounts for key demographic variables there
is not research to back it up
|
The
highly reliable assessment with a scientific base where the teacher can be
confident about the results.
This
assessment is appropriate to group the students in the right reading groups
and know where they stand with reading
The
results on first test and retest can reflect growth in reading
This
test has history to accurately measure students, but you should always look
at other assessments to correctly diagnose the children with reading
difficulties.
|
Slosson
Intelligence Test Primary (SIT-P)
|
Assessment
for 2-7 yr. olds
Covers
121 verbal questions covering vocabulary, comprehension, auditory sentence memory
and short-term memory numbers and 90 nonverbal covering nonverbal spatial
reasoning, visual motor integration and speed of visual processing
Early
screening that allows to identify individual needs and determine if further
assessment or special services are required for the student
|
Quick
assessment that takes less time to administer, score and interpret the
results.
Can
make efficient decision about the student
A
qualified master level educator counselor gives the assessment and they are qualified
to administer, score, and interpret the results to lead to consistent,
accurate decisions
|
The
test for the 2-3 yr. olds is less stable when their environment and responses
are changing drastically
Ignores
the differences and consistencies with gifted students, students with special
needs, lower socioeconomic and at risk populations
Ignores
individual differences and unfair to categorized to get reasonable fit for
educational needs.
|
The
test is more appropriate for the 4-7 yr. old where the results are
consistence where they have the developed knowledge by school age to complete
the test and results are reliable
The
test is less appropriate for 2-3 yr. olds where results are inconsistent
based on their learning experiences
The
test is a helpful tool for getting quick results to provide the student any
additional services they may need
Finally,
you should always look at other assessment to accurately place the student
because you cannot rely on one assessment alone
|
Slosson
Oral Reading Test (SORT)
|
A
quick screening test that looks at oral word recognition and determines a
student’s reading level
A
list of 200 word arranged in order of difficulty. This can be given to students 4 and older
It
can be used to assess a student’s progress, determine grade reading level,
and see if further diagnostic testing is needed
|
Satisfactory
reliability in the results and it test oral reading skills
The
content has been reviewed by experts, textbook authors and compared to
various curriculum guides where the lists have validity
Words
are selected to show reading progress
|
Not
an assessment that measures all aspects of reading such as word knowledge and
comprehension
The
assessment sample has not proven results to show norm data from all
demographic groups or students with special needs to gifted students
|
This
is a quick assessment for screening only you cannot use the results to
determine a student’s reading level without further assessments
This
test is meant for initial screening or research where pair with other tests
and a teacher’s judgment the student can be confidentially classified in the
right reading level
|
Visual
Motor Integration Test (Visual Discrimination Test)
|
There
are two main VMITs : Beery-Buktenica
Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration
(DTVMI) and the Full Range Test of Visual Motor Integration
(FRTVMI) both measure similar visual motor integration constructs
This
help determine if there will be learning disabilities that can be addressed
by measuring visual motor skills
|
This
a quick test that takes 5-15 minutes and is easy to score
Reliable
and unbiased measure of visual motor ability
Can
help diagnose learning disabilities that visual discrimination problems
|
There
can a difference in results based on sex because of maturity
This
cannot be used as a repeated assessment on a student to measure progress
You
only can see assessment at that point in time
|
This
is appropriate as a helpful tool to assess students with visual
discrimination problems that can affect their reading level to determine a
reading plan for them
This
assessment is good for an initial measure and diagnosis, but when looking at
long-term growth a teacher needs to look at other assessment tools
|
Wepman’s
Auditory Discrimination Test
|
Individual
test where the test involves instructing the child to indicate if the word
pairs read aloud are the same or different from 40 pairs of words in five
minutes
An
assessment of student's ability to discriminate between commonly used
phonemes through the measure of the ability hear spoken language
|
Easy
test to administer and score
Can
help identify children who have delayed speech or difficulty with reading
|
Examiner
reliability and background noise for this test can produce results that not
accurately measure the students ability
Not
clear if poor auditory discrimination is significant factor for articulation
problems
Should
be a screening test where major decisions are made about the student
Variation
may result based on rate of presentation and emphasis on word pairs
|
This
test should be use with other assessments and this test can be the initial
measurement to classify students
Again,
should be used to make decisions on determining reading levels
This
is a quick assessment along with the teacher’s judgment can help the students
who are having difficulties with reading
|
References
Erfold, B. and Paulette, D. (2005). Psychometric Analysis of Young
Children's Responses to the Slosson Intelligence Test-Primary (SIT-P). Journal of Measurement and Evaluation in
Counseling and Development. 38(10), 130-140.
Nilsson, N.L.
(2008). A Critical Analysis of Eight Informal Reading Inventories. The Reading Teacher, 61(7), pp. 526-536.
Ruddell, R.
Teaching Children to Read and
Write 4th edition. United States. Pearson.
Wednesday, January 23, 2013
Week 3
Sitting here in class no assignment yet. Our assignment this week was to write about how children learn to read:
Introduction
Every child takes a unique path in learning to read that
can rely on various factors. These
factors can be based on their social environment before they start school. It all starts when we are born being curious
about our surroundings. Babies want to
learn about their environment in which they live. As they develop, they want to learn new
things and how to communicate with their loved ones. How a baby develops really depends on their
social environment. The key ingredient
is that the family is active in introducing them to the world of books. Additionally, the young child learns language
development from listening to their family and peers. They enhance language by listening to the
stories their parents read to them. It
is the introduction to books with decodable pictures that helps a young child
interpret the world around them. The
important role of a parent is to build the excitement of exploring books for
their children. The more the child is
exposed to books, the more likely they will embrace reading. In the early years, it helps to introduce your
child to the library and read each day to them.
Children relate to book that have characters they recognize from
television shows such as Dora or a common experience. They learn to explore a book by decoding the
pictures. The amount of this exposure
will help a teacher take a student to the next level of reading. However, the challenge a teacher faces is
each child she gets has a different level of exposure to language and
books. It is up to the teacher to help
bridge the gap between his/her students in order to help them embrace learning
to read. A teacher needs to understand
the different stages of reading and know it is not easy for everyone to learn
to read. The children need to be given
the tools to be a successful reader.
Most importantly, a teacher needs to realize each student is different
and they need to be assessed to determine their reading level.
Learning
to Read Stages
Each
child begins the process with language development, so they can communicate
with their family and peers. The first
stage is the pre-alphabetic where a child is learning their letters. It is important
to focus on learning letters, letter sounds, and expanding their word
vocabulary. This stage is the most
important because if you do not grasp these concepts, then you will have
difficulties down the road learning to read independently. Usually picture books are used in this stage,
so they can develop picture literacy by learning to interpret the meaning in
the story. The pictures books play an
important role in attracting a student to read by the artistic design elements
and its relation to the text in the story.
This is where the artistic style of the pictures helps the early reader
relate to the mood and setting of the story.
This is enhanced by the student ability to draw pictures to help tell a
story.
The
next two stages early alphabetic and later alphabetic help develop the skills
of phonological awareness, phonics, word recognition, spelling, and repeated
exposure to reading materials. This is
where the students move from sounding out letters to being able to take more cues
on sounding out more complex words. The
best strategies is rhyming words, learning about word families, having spelling
tests, exposing them to new vocabulary, and having them write down their
thoughts. This is taking the student to
the next level and their progress really depends on how they have mastered their
previous skills. Again, having the
student incorporate a home reading program is the key to their success. This stage begins to introduce the students
to leveled readers and chapter books depending on their progress. The students first learn to read by reading
aloud and then move towards reading to them themselves. The teacher needs to have assessments to
understand where each student stands, so they do not get frustrated where they
do not want to read. At this stage, we
want to develop independent readers with minimal frustration. Another main component to reading is keeping
the student’s interest in reading by helping them find stories that interest
them. As a teacher, it is important to
know your student in order to make recommendations on what stories they can
read.
The
next stage is reading fluency where the student has expanding vocabulary and
phonics, and can decipher longer words.
At this level, the student has developed comprehension skills where they
can answer questions about the story they have read. They learn to ask questions to themselves as
the story unfolds. The independent
reader can reflect deeply about the story and write about it. They have a strong understanding of different
genres of books and want to be exposed to new stories that challenge their
minds. The further development of
vocabulary and reading comprehension is explored in depth in grades four and
beyond.
Reading
Development Levels
The
four stages of reading development are called the emergent, early, transition,
and fluent readers. The emergent readers
need books that are going to catch their attention. Primarily, they read picture books where they
can recognize letters, words, and language patterns. They usually want to review the book more
than once with an adult guiding them through the story. The early readers use several strategies or
cues on how the story will unfold by looking for language patterns, the message
in the story, and picture literacy. The
transitional readers like to read books in a series where they can relate to
the characters. They read at a good pace
with a better comprehension of the story.
Fluent readers are independent and can interpret more complex
language. They can gain an understanding
that stories project ideas and can influence one’s ideas. By the
time, the students get to grade four; they should have the skills in place
where they can comprehend what they are reading and be able to read any book in
their grade level or higher. A teacher
should be able to assess the student’s reading level in order to put them in
pace with all fourth graders. Assessment
is the key to understanding where each student stands, so they are not frustrated
and letting the parents know how they can help their child to strengthen their
reading skills.
Conclusion
As a teacher, I
know having a strong reading program in my classroom is important. I need to communicate with parents and stress
the importance of reading at home.
Additionally, I need to keep the interest heighten for my students where
they are excited to read. I want them to
be able to expand their minds and show them how books open new opportunities
for them. By giving them the tools to be
a successful reader, I am giving them the opportunity to excel in life. Reading is not easy for everyone, so it is
important for each student grasp the early stages of reading. Finally, the true success of a student’s
interest in reading is based on the enthusiasm they have been exposed to from
their environment at home, school, and in the community.
Wednesday, January 16, 2013
Week 2
January 16th
Still waiting for placement.
1st research project due: Visual Literacy for Reading Comprehension my prezi link: http://prezi.com/_vnpebikxnbo/visual-literacy/
Introduction
Still waiting for placement.
1st research project due: Visual Literacy for Reading Comprehension my prezi link: http://prezi.com/_vnpebikxnbo/visual-literacy/
Introduction
The
early development of a child starts with the development of language skills within
the home environment. Their literacy
development varies depending on their experiences before starting school. The teacher does not have control over this;
however, they must be able to adapt their instruction based on the literacy
needs of their class. This can vary year
to year depending on the socioeconomic status of the students. The teacher can assess their students and
determine the best path to take in developing reading comprehension
skills. Oral language skills are not the
only mode of communication. Written communication is also developed by a child
before school by drawing pictures on what they see in their environment. Through the development of these early skills
of communication, a child is able to become an emergent reader or writer
through the introduction of picture books.
The literacy development of a child is important by exposing them early
to pictures, so they can gain interest in reading. The first step is for the parents to develop
a literacy program at home by reading to their children, which will be further
enhanced in school by their teachers.
Starting in Pre-K, the teachers already start teaching their student
visual literacy by asking questions about a story. The teacher does this by asking the students
to interpret the pictures in the story.
An example of this is showing the students pictures from the story and
asking them to put them in order based on the main events in the story. The teacher needs to set the foundation for a
visual literacy program where students are able to strengthen their literacy
skills by making the connection between the words in a story and its pictures.
Visual
Literacy Main Components
Pictures books help children make
the connection to a story by its illustrations.
An illustration can tell us the mood and setting of a story where we can
see pictorial interpretations of the characters in the setting of the
story. The pictorial properties in the
illustration include color, shape, line, size, and style. This helps the students make that special
connection between the text and its pictures.
It helps the child visualize the story and be able to see the story in
both the author’s and illustrator’s eyes.
Some of our classic fairytales would not be the same without the
illustrations. The illustrations help
tell the story along with the text. This helps them gain an understanding in developing
early reading comprehension skills.
Also, the students learn to understand the main idea of a story by being
able to summarize the story’s main events.
The teacher can help by using tools such as a Venn diagram or a graphic
organizer or a story map.
The
basic design elements are picture to text interaction where the illustrations
reinforce, describe, and establish a connection to the story. The way a teacher can teach these skills is making
color and cultural connections, explaining how style implies the setting and
makes the tone, and the composition that makes the characters and main plot of
the story. Teachers can help the students
make these connections by teaching the components of visual literacy and
reading different genres of books. By
exposing the students to a variety of books, they can begin to understand how
to connect the illustrations to the story.
The more stories they are exposed to the stronger their visual literacy
skills will be developed. Another key
component to developing their visual literacy skills is to have the parents
reinforce it at home with a home reading program. Both the parents and the school are important
partners in developing their child’s reading comprehension. Visual literacy can be developed by looking
at the text to text connections, inference, visualizing, interpreting the main
idea, and answering questions about the story.
Conclusion
As a teacher, I
believe visual literacy is a major component to reading comprehension. The illustrations help us understand and
expand our creative minds in understanding how a story unfolds. Without the pictures in a story, how would we
get the same details in a story? The
illustrations bring the story to life and help open the eyes of the children to
a wonderful world of reading. This
article definitely emphasizes the importance of visual literacy. The more exposure the students have to reading,
the more likely they will be avid readers. By enhancing their visual skills it
help them comprehend the stories they have read, which in turn opens a new
world for them.
Wednesday, January 9, 2013
My first night in Practicum III
I am sitting in my first night of Practicum III absorbing the new assignments for this block. Wow!
- Research article next week with Prezi due week 2
- Summary of how children learn to read due week 3
- SEA week due week 4
- Critique of 5 resources due week 6
- BRI due week 7
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)